How we score
Short version: the Ugly Score is an opinion, and a playful one.
The Ugly Score (our take)
Each exhibit gets an Ugly Score from 0 to 100. Higher means the design more strongly channels an earlier era of the web. It’s a subjective, lighthearted editorial measure, not an objective assessment, and it says nothing about the business itself.
When an editor sets a score, they consider a few visual criteria:
- Visual style: how much the colors, fonts, textures and graphics belong to a bygone trend.
- Mobile friendliness (our impression): how the page looks on a phone-sized screen.
- Clarity of layout: how easy it is to see where things are.
These sub-scores are shown on listings as our impression, labelled as such.
Community verdict
Visitors vote on the most memorable design detail from a short list of quirks, and can upvote exhibits they love. Every count you see comes from real votes. Each visitor gets one quirk vote per exhibit and can change it at any time.
The quirks we use:
- Dated layout
- Awkward on mobile
- Wall of text
- Clashing colors
- Tiny fonts
- Stock photo overload
- Mystery navigation
- Cluttered menus
- Animated GIF overload
- Stale-looking styling
- Blurry images
- Popups and autoplay
Measured facts
Separately from opinions, listings show a few facts recorded automatically when the screenshots were captured:
- Whether the page was served over HTTPS.
- Whether it has a mobile viewport tag, and whether it scrolls sideways on a 390-pixel-wide phone screen.
- The latest copyright year found in the footer.
- A Google PageSpeed Insights mobile score, only when we actually ran the test, with the date it was measured.
- The capture date. The live site may have changed since.
We never describe a site as broken or slow based on how it looks.